Feedstock Adjustments: The R&D Tax Rule Founders Miss

Sell what your R&D batch produces and the ATO claws back part of your R&D refund. Here's exactly how feedstock adjustments work, with a worked example.

You run a batch through your R&D process, it works better than expected, and instead of binning the output you sell it or ship it to an early customer. That one decision can trigger a feedstock adjustment on your R&D Tax Incentive claim, and most founders have never heard the term until their accountant mentions it.

Here’s what it actually is, what sets it off, how the number gets calculated, and who it catches.

What a feedstock adjustment actually is

Under the R&D Tax Incentive, feedstock expenditure covers three things: money spent on goods or materials (“feedstock inputs”) that get transformed or processed during your R&D activities to produce tangible products (“feedstock outputs”); energy that goes directly into that transformation; and the decline in value of assets used to acquire or produce those inputs.

This applies to both core and supporting R&D activities, and it isn’t limited to manufacturing. The ATO’s own guidance extends it to agriculture, livestock, aquaculture and horticulture, so if you’re running a pilot crop, a test aquaculture batch or a small production run of a physical product, this rule is relevant to you.

The idea behind it is simple. The government doesn’t want to fund the cost of developing something and then let you keep the full R&D offset on top of whatever you make selling the thing you developed. If your R&D process produces a sellable output, some of what you claimed gets clawed back.

That third category, decline in value of assets used to acquire or produce feedstock inputs, catches equipment depreciation too. If you bought or leased a piece of processing equipment specifically to produce the feedstock inputs for your R&D, the portion of its decline in value that you claimed as a notional deduction is part of what gets factored into the adjustment, not just the raw materials and energy costs.

What actually triggers it

A feedstock adjustment is triggered in the income year you sell or supply the feedstock output, or a marketable product made from it, or apply it to your own use. Using it internally doesn’t let you off the hook unless that use is itself further transformation for supply.

Affiliates and connected entities count too, so moving the output sideways into a related entity before selling it doesn’t avoid the adjustment.

The trigger doesn’t have to land in the same year as your original claim. If you ran the R&D two years ago and only just found a buyer for the leftover batch, the adjustment applies in the year you sell it, not the year you claimed the expenditure.

A failed batch isn’t automatically safe either. The trigger is the sale or the use, not whether the experiment achieved what you set out to prove. A batch that technically failed your hypothesis but still works well enough to sell still counts.

How the number actually gets calculated

If you sell the feedstock output as-is, feedstock revenue is just the sale price. If you process it further before selling, the ATO apportions it: market value of the finished marketable product, multiplied by the cost of producing the feedstock output divided by the cost of producing the marketable product.

From there, the clawback amount is the lesser of two figures: the feedstock expenditure reasonably attributable to that output, or the feedstock revenue you just worked out.

That clawback amount then gets converted into assessable income through a formula that compares the R&D offset you actually received against the offset you would have received if the feedstock expenditure had never been claimed, minus the tax you’d have paid on that expenditure anyway, then grosses the result back up at your company tax rate.

If you’ve seen this described somewhere as “a third of whichever figure is smaller,” that’s an old shorthand that doesn’t match the current calculation. Don’t use it.

A worked example

Say your company spent $22,000 in notional R&D deductions on a project, and $10,000 of that was feedstock expenditure on the materials and energy used to produce a batch of physical output. You sell that batch for $9,000. Your company tax rate is 25% and you’re eligible for the 43.5% refundable offset.

The clawback amount is the lesser of $10,000 (feedstock expenditure) and $9,000 (feedstock revenue), so $9,000.

Your starting offset was $22,000 times 43.5%, which is $9,570. The offset you’d have received without that $9,000 of feedstock expenditure is $13,000 times 43.5%, which is $5,655. The tax you would have paid on that $9,000 if you hadn’t claimed it is $9,000 times 25%, which is $2,250.

$9,570 minus $5,655 minus $2,250 leaves $1,665. Divide that by your 25% tax rate and you get $6,660, which is what gets added to your assessable income in the year you sell the batch.

You still come out ahead overall, since the refund on the original claim was bigger than the adjustment. But that $6,660 shows up as taxable income in a specific year, and if you haven’t modelled it, it lands as a surprise on a tax bill you weren’t expecting.

Who this actually catches

Hardware and manufacturing founders running prototype or pilot batches that end up good enough to sell. A test run of a new device or component often produces more units than you need for validation, and the leftover stock is exactly the kind of output this rule is built for.

Agtech and foodtech founders running test crops, trial feeds or small production runs where the output has commercial value from the start, not as an afterthought. If your R&D activity is a field trial that still produces a harvestable crop, or a pilot batch of a new food product that’s good enough to put on shelves, the ATO treats that the same way as a factory prototype.

Biotech and materials science companies scaling up a process where the pilot run itself becomes saleable stock, rather than something that gets destroyed in testing.

It generally doesn’t catch you for selling or licensing intellectual property, know-how or a design on its own, because the rule is built around tangible feedstock outputs, not knowledge. Software founders mostly never encounter this, which is why it barely comes up outside hardware, manufacturing and primary production conversations.

A few questions we get asked

What if the output becomes an input for a later R&D project instead of being sold? Using it as a feedstock input for the next round of R&D doesn’t trigger the adjustment at that stage. It’s only sale, supply, or application to your own use outside of further R&D that sets it off.

What if I give the batch away instead of selling it? Applying it to your own use, or disposing of it, still counts. The adjustment is based on market value where there’s no sale price to use.

What if the batch is a complete failure and gets scrapped? Then there’s no feedstock output to adjust, because nothing was sold, supplied or used. The rule only bites once something marketable actually changes hands.

Common mistakes

Not tracking feedstock expenditure separately from the rest of your core and supporting activity costs, which makes it impossible to work out what’s “reasonably attributable” to a given output when the time comes.

Assuming a test batch is safe because it wasn’t the actual goal of the experiment. The trigger is the sale, not the intention.

Forgetting that the adjustment can show up years after the original claim, once a buyer finally turns up for output you’d written off.

Not checking what affiliates and connected entities do with the output, since their sales count too.

What to do about it

Flag any R&D activity that could produce a sellable physical output at the start of the project, not after someone’s already bought the batch. Keep separate cost records for feedstock inputs, energy and any further processing, because the apportionment calculation needs both sets of numbers. Build the possibility of a future feedstock adjustment into your cash flow forecasting, especially if you’re sitting on test batches or pilot runs that might eventually find a buyer.

This matters beyond the tax return too. If you’re raising a round or going through due diligence, an investor’s accountant will sometimes ask whether your R&D claims account for feedstock. Having already worked out the calculation, rather than discovering it mid-raise, is the difference between a quick answer and a stalled data room.

It also matters if the sale happens well after the claim. A batch sitting in a warehouse for two years before it finally sells still triggers the adjustment in the year it’s sold, using the rules and rates that applied in the original claim year. That’s a calculation worth getting an adviser to run properly rather than estimating, because the inputs span two different financial years and two different sets of figures.

We’ve unlocked more than $7.9 million in R&D refunds for 55+ clients, with a 100% success rate and zero audits, and working out a feedstock position is part of that for any hardware, agtech or manufacturing claim where it applies. If you’re not sure whether your R&D process is about to produce something sellable, or you’ve already sold a batch and aren’t sure what that means for your claim, book a quick eligibility conversation at granton.io/meet.

 

Are you ready to turn your funding aspirations into reality? At Granton, we specialize in helping individuals and businesses navigate the world of grants, offering expert guidance on grant applications and finding opportunities that best suit their needs. Whether you’re seeking funding for a startup, nonprofit, or a specific project, our team is here to assist you every step of the way. We take the guesswork out of Grant Applications, R&D Tax Incentives, and Accelerator Programs, making the process smoother and increasing your chances of success. Ready to take the next step? Book a free consultation with us today, and let’s explore how we can help you secure the grants you deserve. Visit our website at granton.io to learn more or use our contact form to get in touch. Your grant journey starts here!

Scroll to Top